Book Review of Amy B. Greenfields A Perfect Red: Empire, Espionage, and the Quest for the color of Desire
Content:
1. Introduction
2. A Perfect Red- an interesting and useful reading
3. Conclusion
4. Bibliography
Introduction
What colour would you use to underline the most important information in the
advertisement? What colour does human eye distinguish best of all in the dark?
What colour symbolises blood and passion at the same time? The most of the people
will guess this colour without any difficulty. It’s a red colour. For
majority it’s just one of the colours of colour palette, not worse or
better than the others. It doesn’t come to our minds that the colour could
be the reason of wars, the object of espionage, could cause the growth or fall
or the whole Empires. Therefore these are historical facts, stated in Amy Greenfield’s
historic research. The whole book is dedicated to one red colour, but it touches
almost all the aspects concerning to red – its history, its use, its production,
its chemical mixture, etc.
Amy B. Greenfield’s A Perfect Red: Empire, Espionage, and the Quest for
the colour of Desire is a perfect mixture of entertaining read you can’t
get your eyes off with the informative and useful information on many fields,
such as business history, chemistry, biology and even psychology and advertisement.
A Perfect Red – an interesting and useful reading
I’ve read the book in one breath. I would never have thought the history
of one colour could be so fascinated, so tragic, powerful and symbolic. A Perfect
Red is a story how the colour ruled people, occupied their minds, made them
obsessed.
In her book Amy uncovers many interesting facts from the history of red colour
and important role it has played during the centuries. For many monarchs, kings
and governors this colour symbolised prestige, power and higher position. As
Greenfield writes, “Elusive, expensive, and invested with powerful symbolism,
red cloth became the prized possession of the wealthy and well-born.”
(Greenfield, 68). Montezuma, great Aztec chief, insisted on his exclusive right
to wear the brightest shades of the red as necessary attribute of his wealth
and power. Such examples are multiple. The attitude to this colour could be
different in different cultures and historical periods, but by major part it
was the colour of the higher society, symbolising its uniqueness. The answer
to the question why this happened becomes evident after we read the book. From
the book we understand it was a real problem to get a red dye of high quality.
The colours achieved from the plant sources such as henna or madder and insects
such as Laccifer lacca were not bright enough or had some other shades. It also
faded away very quickly. So those, who wanted to wear or use things of a perfect
colour, had to pay big money for shipping it from other countries.
In her book, Greenfield put her detailed investigation about the export of cochineal
by Spanish trades people. While making some investigations on other topic, she
became intrigued by the quantity of cargo manifests of Spanish trade ships in
16-17 century. They were exporting cochineal – the basic component for
the perfect red dye. After detailed investigation, Amy got an interesting history
of “perfect” colour, which she presented in her book.
She centres he narration around cochineal - a product of organic origin, which
was used to produce vibrant red dye. Cochineal helped to produced “brightest,
strongest red the Old World had ever seen” And was praised as gold by
Europeans, who hadn’t seen such a perfect red dye before. Greenfield gives
a detailed history analysis of the matter, which doesn’t leave any blank
sports and misunderstandings. Great research work, performed by the author is
expressed in a perfect literary work, which is read like a novel. The depth
of research is proved also by the list of the references at the end of the book,
which gives the field for further reading or provides necessary proves, if necessary.
From the ancient time people were interested in the power the colour had on
our mood and consciousness. It’s a common fact, that red colour is one
of the most influential ones of the colour pallet. From the old times red served
for the clothes of people who belonged to upper class and was a symbol or wealth
and nobility. In this way, red colour had not only psychological impact and
social importance, but also high economical value with the direct financial
equivalent.
The Spanish made a great breakthrough after discovering the secret of “true
red”. When conquistadors invaded Mexico, they could not first believe
their eyes when saw their clothes made of materials, dyed in perfectly red colour.
Native settlers – Aztecs possessed the secret of the producing of this
colour and also praised it, by the way. Soon the secret of production was uncovered.
The red was produced with the help of cochineal – a substance achieved
from the insects which inhabited only that part of the world. These tiny insects
of unknown origin (scientists spent a lot of time, debating if they were insects
at all and creating of the microscope is partially explained by the necessity
to uncover this enigma) could survive eating only special kinds of host plant,
the nopal. As soon as the secret of the dye production was discovered, the Spanish
made sure to monopolise this profitable secret, making it the prerogative of
the Spanish Empire. Very quickly Spain became the dominant exporter of the red
dye to Europe. Europe dyers and manufacturers had to follow conditions of Spanish
tradespeoples, who posses an absolute monopoly on the cochineal production.
Then Amy retells the story of struggle – struggle for the commercial secret
of cochineal production, which’s kept Spain’s monopoly to this dye
in the whole world. Greenfield states that this fact influenced the international
trade and politics for centuries and proves her thesis with many arguments.
I think that this book contains interesting and important facts from business
history as it partially explains the reasons of prosperity of Spain during several
centuries. “The story that Butler Greenfield tells rests on an impressive
mountain of scholarship that is hidden from the reader by wavy prose that carry
us effortlessly between the colonial European powers and the locales in the
West Indies and the Spanish Main where the cochineal beetle was cultivated”
(Liss). The story is also interested because it contains the depiction of the
methods, business rivals used to uncover the secret of “mysterious dye”.
Commercial espionage, private investigations, bribes and graft – all the
mean were used by the rivals. Even scientists were involved into this international
intrigue, as they had to guess the origin of the black “seeds” –
cochineal imported from Mexico. Pirates’ attacks add to the picture of
“red gold” popularisation all over the world. Pirates watched Spanish
ships loaded with cochineal and robbed them. It was an object of additional
national pride for British privateers to bring home mysterious red dye from
the robbed Spanish ships. European countries, dependant on Spain were looking
for alternative ways to achieve the dye in order to get rid of “shameful”
dependence from Spain. Finally, the invention of the synthetic red dye at the
end of 19the century brought to end Spanish domination on the market of dye
production. After this invention, multiple farms specialised on the cochineal
production became bankrupts as the technology of cochineal production was time-consuming
and expansive and couldn’t stand the competition with the synthetic production.
It was a hard blow for the owners of small farms in Guatemala, Mexico and Canary
Islands that had to close their farms as there was no need in cochineal production
any more. It’s a typical situation when changes in an important industry
lead to major social and economic disruption. Modern trade practices often have
similar effects in many poorer countries. I think that facts, which show how
technical development and innovations can influence business, economy, and even
the political structure of the world, are very interesting and edifying.
Conclusion
I think that this is the way historical books are to be written in order to
attract the wide audience. A Perfect Red is “stuffed” with historic,
business information, explores the whole epoch in the history of many countries,
but, at the same time, fascinates us with interesting plot and subject. This
book is a perfect find for those, who get bored of dull reports with much statistics
and uninteresting account of the historic events. It contributes too many sciences,
but, the most essential contribution it makes to the history of business, to
my mind. It gives unique information about the history of discovery and export
of essential component – cochineal. The chemical information for those,
who are interested in the chemical qualities of the dyes, is also very interested.
The language is rich but understandable at the same time, so those, who are
not professional in one or another field, will also be able to get through the
text without much difficulty. I would like to underline the thing I’ve
mentioned before. We can count on the arguments, cited by the author as we can
check them ourselves, using the rich list of references to the source used when
writing a book. This information can be also very necessary for those, who got
really interested in the subject or any its aspects and wants to continue his
own investigation himself.
Bibliography
1. Greenfield Amy Butler (2005) A Perfect Red: Empire, Espionage, and the Quest
for the Color of Desire, HarperCollins, 338 pp.
2. http://www.amybutlergreenfield.com/
3. Liss, Barbara, Seeing red A history of the world’s fascination with
the color of fire and desire


